慢性意识障碍患者结局预测模型的系统综述

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1006-9771.2022.02.009

Abstract

Abstract:

Objective To systematicly evaluate the constituent factors and accuracy of prediction models of outcome for patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness. Methods Articles about prediction models of outcome for patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness were retrieved from PubMed, Web of Science, CNKI and Wanfang Data until September 30th, 2021. The authors, publishing times, subjects, predictive indicators, outcomes and conclusions were extracted. Results A total of 4 313 articles were returned and 37 included, comprising randomized controlled trials and cohort studies, which published mainly from 2012 to 2021. The subjects were patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness, and their predictions consisted of clinical assessment scales, neuroimaging, neuroelectrophysiology and laboratory indicators. Conclusion Prediction models may be valuable for the long-term outcomes of patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness. Most of the current prediction models are composed of only a limited number of technical means, and the accuracy is uneven. Coma Recovery Scale-revised, default mode network and multiple evoked potentials-related prediction models are accurate, but lack a unified adaptation standard.

Key words: disorders of consciousness, outcome, prediction model, systematic review

CLC Number:

R741

YU Kuai,ZHANG Li,YE Xiangming. Prediction models of outcome for patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness: a systematic review[J]. 《Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice》, 2022, 28(2): 190-198.

Figures/Tables 2

纳入文献	研究对象	监测项目	主要结局指标	结论
唐秋月等^[1](2020)	脑卒中、GCS < 8	GCS、FOUR、mRS	mRS 5~6分,预后不良;mRS 0~4分,预后良好	FOUR对预后的评估能力优于GCS
Estraneo等^[2](2013)	pDoC	CRS-R	意识恢复情况	CRS-R是意识恢复的显著独立预测因素
Bodien等^[3](2016)	意识障碍	CRS-R	觉醒程度	CRS-R可识别MCS与EMCS
Sattin等^[4](2015)	成年人,意识障碍	CRS-R	觉醒程度	CRS-R修正评分可提示患者预后
Pincherle等^[5](2019)	16岁以上,pDoC	CRS-R、MBT-r	GOS	MBT-r可作为CRS-R的补充使预后预测更精准
Aubinet等^[6](2021)	18岁以上,pDoC	CRS-R、SECONDs	意识状态	SECONDs简便有效
Thibaut等^[7](2012)	意识障碍	fMRI	意识状态	皮质网络代谢与CRS-R正相关
Sitt等^[8](2014)	意识障碍	fMRI	意识状态	DMN连接强度与意识水平显著相关
Silva等^[9](2015)	GCS < 8	fMRI	CRS-R	脑功能连接与患者未来的神经恢复之间存在显著关联性
Di Perri等^[10](2016)	意识障碍	fMRI	意识状态	默认网络和执行控制网络之间的负功能连接可预测预后
Stender等^[11](2015)	意识障碍	fMRI	CRS-R	皮质代谢率和意识水平恢复之间存在显著相关性
Yu等^[12](2021)	意识障碍	fMRI	GOS-E	FC是最准确的单因子预测模型,因子预测模型优于单因子
Song等^[13](2018)	意识障碍	fMRI	CRS-R、GOS	多领域预后模型准确高
Wang等^[14](2015)	VS/UWS	fMRI	CRS-R	听觉皮质的激活类型和激活量与预后显著相关
Okumura等^[15](2014)	意识障碍	fMRI	意识状态	颞上回激活可能预示意识状态改善
Monti等^[16](2013)	意识障碍	EEG	意识状态	视觉认知与预后有所关联
Babiloni等^[17](2009)	意识障碍	EEG	认知功能水平量表	α振荡可能为意识恢复的预测因素
Hofmeijer等^[18](2015)	意识障碍	EEG	EEG特征	弥散性慢波提示预后良好;等电位、低电压或爆发波的爆发性抑制提示预后不良
Schnakers等^[19](2008)	缺氧缺血性脑病后意识障碍	EEG	意识状态	脑电双频指数与GCS和CRS-R评分显著正相关
Holeckova等^[20](2006)	意识障碍	EEG	意识状态	唤名刺激能预测结局
Pan等^[21](2014)	意识障碍	EEG	脑机接口设备是否检出命令跟随	视觉刺激可以检测意识障碍患者残存的意识
Venturella等^[22](2019)	意识障碍	EEG	意识状态	痛觉是意识障碍患者预后分析良好的预测因子
Chéliout-Heraut等^[23](2001)	意识障碍	EEG	意识状态	睡眠纺锤波是有利预后预测因子
Wislowska等^[24](2017)	儿童,GCS < 5	EEG	CRS-R	睡眠纺锤波密度与CRS-R评分呈线性正相关
Zheng等^[25](2013)	意识障碍	EEG	意识状态	早期体感诱发电位缺失的患者均预后不良
Cavinato等^[26](2009)	弥漫性轴索损伤、意识障碍	EEG	意识是否恢复	P300是VS患者意识恢复的一个强有力的预测因子
Luaute等^[27](2010)	VS	EEG	GOS	中潜伏期听觉诱发电位皮质成分缺失与意识恶化有关
翁绮贞等^[28](2021)	GCS < 8	脑干听觉诱发电位、EEG	是否觉醒	脑干听觉诱发电位联合EEG评估预后准确性高
方红^[29](2015)	GCS < 8	脑干听觉诱发电位、体感诱发电位	死亡、VS：预后不良;恢复良好、轻或重的残疾：预后良好	脑干听觉诱发电位、体感诱发电位有助于预后预测
Kotchoubey等^[30](2005)	VS、MCS	EEG	意识状态	失匹配负波可有效预测预后
Steppacher等^[31](2020)	PVS、MCS	EEG	意识是否恢复	N400与P300联合应用有良好的预后预测能力
Casarotto等^[32](2016)	意识障碍	TMS-EEG	意识状态是否改善	PCI_max > 0.31预示良好结局
Kellermann等^[33](2016)	MCS、VS	S100B	GOS	血清中S100B > 0.7 ng/mL必然造成死亡的临床结局
Lei等^[34](2015)	意识障碍	GFAP	GOS	血清GFAP升高是不良结局的预测因子
Czeiter等^[35](2012)	意识障碍	GFAP	是否存活	GFAP血清值与致死率显著正相关
Mondello等^[36](2016)	意识障碍	GFAP、UCH-L1、S100B	GOS	GFAP和UCH-L1可预测不良结局
Žurek等^[37](2012)	意识障碍	Tau蛋白	GOS	Tau蛋白与预后相关性尚不明确

References 46

[1]	唐秋月, 韩睿, 施颖, 等. 昏迷量表定量分析对重症脑血管病预后评估的研究[J]. 交通医学, 2020, 34(6): 593-595.
	TANG Q Y, HAN R, SHI Y, et al. Quantitative analysis of coma scale for prognosis evaluation of severe cerebrovascular disease[J]. Med J Comm, 2020, 34(6): 593-595.
[2]	ESTRANEO A, MORETTA P, LORETO V, et al. Predictors of recovery of responsiveness in prolonged anoxic vegetative state[J]. Neurology, 2013, 80(5): 464-470. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0b013e31827f0f31
[3]	BODIEN Y G, CARLOWICZ C A, CHATELLE C, et al. Sensitivity and specificity of the Coma Recovery Scale-Revised Total Score in detection of conscious awareness[J]. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 2016, 97(3): 490-492. doi: 10.1016/j.apmr.2015.08.422
[4]	SATTIN D, MINATI L, ROSSI D, et al. The Coma Recovery Scale Modified Score: a new scoring system for the Coma Recovery Scale-revised for assessment of patients with disorders of consciousness[J]. Int J Rehabil Res, 2015, 38(4): 350-356. doi: 10.1097/MRR.0000000000000135
[5]	PINCHERLE A, JOHR J, CHATELLE C, et al. Motor behavior unmasks residual cognition in disorders of consciousness[J]. Ann Neurol, 2019, 85(3): 443-447. doi: 10.1002/ana.25417
[6]	AUBINET C, CASSOL H, BODART O, et al. Simplified evaluation of CONsciousness disorders (SECONDs) in individuals with severe brain injury: a validation study[J]. Ann Phys Rehabil Med, 2021, 64(5): 101432. doi: 10.1016/j.rehab.2020.09.001
[7]	THIBAUT A, BRUNO M, CHATELLE C, et al. Metabolic activity in external and internal awareness networks in severely brain-damaged patients[J]. J Rehabil Med, 2012, 44(6): 487-494. doi: 10.2340/16501977-0940
[8]	SITT J D, KING J R, EL K I, et al. Large scale screening of neural signatures of consciousness in patients in a vegetative or minimally conscious state[J]. Brain, 2014, 137(Pt 8): 2258-2270. doi: 10.1093/brain/awu141
[9]	SILVA S, de PASQUALE F, VUILLAUME C, et al. Disruption of posteromedial large-scale neural communication predicts recovery from coma[J]. Neurology, 2015, 85(23): 2036-2044. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000002196
[10]	DI PERRI C, BAHRI M A, AMICO E, et al. Neural correlates of consciousness in patients who have emerged from a minimally conscious state: a cross-sectional multimodal imaging study[J]. Lancet Neurol, 2016, 15(8): 830-842. doi: 10.1016/S1474-4422(16)00111-3
[11]	STENDER J, KUPERS R, RODELL A, et al. Quantitative rates of brain glucose metabolism distinguish minimally conscious from vegetative state patients[J]. J Cereb Blood Flow Metab, 2015, 35(1): 58-65. doi: 10.1038/jcbfm.2014.169
[12]	YU Y, MENG F, ZHANG L, et al. A multi-domain prognostic model of disorder of consciousness using resting-state fMRI and laboratory parameters[J]. Brain Imaging Behav, 2021, 15(4): 1966-1976. doi: 10.1007/s11682-020-00390-8
[13]	SONG M, YANG Y, HE J, et al. Prognostication of chronic disorders of consciousness using brain functional networks and clinical characteristics[J]. Elife, 2018, 7: e36173. doi: 10.7554/eLife.36173
[14]	WANG F, DI H, HU X, et al. Cerebral response to subject's own name showed high prognostic value in traumatic vegetative state[J]. BMC Med, 2015, 13: 83. doi: 10.1186/s12916-015-0330-7
[15]	OKUMURA Y, ASANO Y, TAKENAKA S, et al. Brain activation by music in patients in a vegetative or minimally conscious state following diffuse brain injury[J]. Brain Inj, 2014, 28(7): 944-950. doi: 10.3109/02699052.2014.888477
[16]	MONTI M M, PICKARD J D, OWEN A M. Visual cognition in disorders of consciousness: from V1 to top-down attention[J]. Hum Brain Mapp, 2013, 34(6): 1245-1253. doi: 10.1002/hbm.v34.6
[17]	BABILONI C, SARA M, VECCHIO F, et al. Cortical sources of resting-state alpha rhythms are abnormal in persistent vegetative state patients[J]. Clin Neurophysiol, 2009, 120(4): 719-729. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2009.02.157
[18]	HOFMEIJER J, BEERNINK T M J, BOSCH F H, et al. Early EEG contributes to multimodal outcome prediction of postanoxic coma[J]. Neurology, 2015, 85(2): 137-143. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000001742
[19]	SCHNAKERS C, LEDOUX D, MAJERUS S, et al. Diagnostic and prognostic use of bispectral index in coma, vegetative state and related disorders[J]. Brain Inj, 2008, 22(12): 926-931. doi: 10.1080/02699050802530565
[20]	HOLECKOVA I, FISCHER C, GIARD M H, et al. Brain responses to a subject's own name uttered by a familiar voice[J]. Brain Res, 2006, 1082(1): 142-152. doi: 10.1016/j.brainres.2006.01.089
[21]	PAN J, XIE Q, HE Y, et al. Detecting awareness in patients with disorders of consciousness using a hybrid brain-computer interface[J]. J Neural Eng, 2014, 11(5): 56007. doi: 10.1088/1741-2560/11/5/056007
[22]	VENTURELLA I, CRIVELLI D, FOSSATI M, et al. EEG and autonomic responses to nociceptive stimulation in disorders of consciousness[J]. J Clin Neurosci, 2019, 60: 101-106. doi: 10.1016/j.jocn.2018.09.020
[23]	CHÉLIOUT-HERAUT F, RUBINSZTAJN R, IOOS C, et al. Prognostic value of evoked potentials and sleep recordings in the prolonged comatose state of children. Preliminary data[J]. Neurophysiol Clin, 2001, 31(5): 283-292. doi: 10.1016/S0987-7053(01)00270-2
[24]	WISLOWSKA M, DEL GIUDICE R, LECHINGER J, et al. Night and day variations of sleep in patients with disorders of consciousness[J]. Sci Rep, 2017, 7(1): 266. doi: 10.1038/s41598-017-00323-4
[25]	ZHENG X, CHEN M, LI J, et al. Prognosis in prolonged coma patients with diffuse axonal injury assessed by somatosensory evoked potentia[J]. Neural Regen Res, 2013, 8(10): 948-954.
[26]	CAVINATO M, FREO U, ORI C, et al. Post-acute P300 predicts recovery of consciousness from traumatic vegetative state[J]. Brain Inj, 2009, 23(12): 973-980. doi: 10.3109/02699050903373493
[27]	LUAUTE J, MAUCORT-BOULCH D, TELL L, et al. Long-term outcomes of chronic minimally conscious and vegetative states[J]. Neurology, 2010, 75(3): 246-252. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0b013e3181e8e8df
[28]	翁绮贞, 梁灼源, 莫锦有, 等. 脑干听觉诱发电位联合脑电图监测对意识障碍患者预后的评估价值[J]. 医疗装备, 2021, 34(8): 4-5.
	WENG Q Z, LIANG Z Y, MO J Y, et al. Prognostic value of brainstem auditory evoked potential combined with EEG monitoring in patients with disorders of consciousness[J]. Med Equip, 2021, 34(8): 4-5.
[29]	方红. 脑干听觉诱发电位联合体感诱发电位对昏迷患者预后评估的临床价值[J]. 中国实用神经疾病杂志, 2015, 18(16): 77-78.
	FANG H. Clinical value of brainstem auditory evoked potential combined with somatosensory evoked potential in evaluating the prognosis of comatose patients[J]. Chin J Pract Nerv Dis, 2015, 18(16): 77-78.
[30]	KOTCHOUBEY B, LANG S, MEZGER G, et al. Information processing in severe disorders of consciousness: vegetative state and minimally conscious state[J]. Clin Neurophysiol, 2005, 116(10): 2441-2453. doi: 10.1016/j.clinph.2005.03.028
[31]	STEPPACHER I, FUCHS P, KAPS M, et al. A tree of life? Multivariate logistic outcome-prediction in disorders of consciousness[J]. Brain Inj, 2020, 34(3): 399-406. doi: 10.1080/02699052.2019.1695289
[32]	CASAROTTO S, COMANDUCCI A, ROSANOVA M, et al. Stratification of unresponsive patients by an independently validated index of brain complexity[J]. Ann Neurol, 2016, 80(5): 718-729. doi: 10.1002/ana.v80.5
[33]	KELLERMANN I, KLEINDIENST A, HORE N, et al. Early CSF and serum S100B concentrations for outcome prediction in traumatic brain injury and subarachnoid hemorrhage[J]. Clin Neurol Neurosurg, 2016, 145: 79-83. doi: 10.1016/j.clineuro.2016.04.005
[34]	LEI J, GAO G, FENG J, et al. Glial fibrillary acidic protein as a biomarker in severe traumatic brain injury patients: a prospective cohort study[J]. Critical Care (London, England), 2015, 19(1): 362. doi: 10.1186/s13054-015-1081-8
[35]	CZEITER E, MONDELLO S, KOVACS N, et al. Brain injury biomarkers may improve the predictive power of the IMPACT outcome calculator[J]. J Neurotr, 2012, 29(9): 1770-1778. doi: 10.1089/neu.2011.2127
[36]	MONDELLO S, KOBEISSY F, VESTRI A, et al. Serum concentrations of ubiquitin C-terminal hydrolase-L1 and glial fibrillary acidic protein after pediatric traumatic brain injury[J]. Sci Rep, 2016, 6: 28203. doi: 10.1038/srep28203
[37]	ŽUREK J, FEDORA M. The usefulness of S100B, NSE, GFAP, NF-H, secretagogin and Hsp70 as a predictive biomarker of outcome in children with traumatic brain injury[J]. Acta Neurochir (Wien), 2012, 154(1): 93-103. doi: 10.1007/s00701-011-1175-2
[38]	TEASDALE G. Assessment of head injuries[J]. Br J Anaesth, 1976, 48(8): 761-766. doi: 10.1093/bja/48.8.761
[39]	MATIS G, BIRBILIS T. The Glasgow Coma Scale: a brief review. Past, present, future[J]. Acta Neurol Belg, 2008, 108(3): 75-89.
[40]	WIJDICKS E F M, BAMLET W R, MARAMATTOM B V, et al. Validation of a new coma scale: The FOUR score[J]. Ann Neurol, 2005, 58(4): 585-593. doi: 10.1002/(ISSN)1531-8249
[41]	GIACINO J T, KEZMARSKY M A, DELUCA J, et al. Monitoring rate of recovery to predict outcome in minimally responsive patients[J]. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 1991, 72(11): 897-901. doi: 10.1016/0003-9993(91)90008-7
[42]	GIACINO J T, KALMAR K, WHYTE J. The JFK Coma Recovery Scale-Revised: Measurement characteristics and diagnostic utility[J]. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 2004, 85(12): 2020-2029. doi: 10.1016/j.apmr.2004.02.033
[43]	SCHIFF N D. Cognitive motor dissociation following severe brain injuries[J]. JAMA Neurol, 2015, 72(12): 1413-1415. doi: 10.1001/jamaneurol.2015.2899
[44]	FAN L, LI H, ZHUO J, et al. The human brainnetome atlas: a new brain atlas based on connectional architecture[J]. Cerebral Cortex, 2016, 26(8): 3508-3526. doi: 10.1093/cercor/bhw157
[45]	LAUREYS S, GOLDMAN S, PHILLIPS C, et al. Impaired effective cortical connectivity in vegetative state: preliminary investigation using PET[J]. Neuroimage, 1999, 9(4): 377-382. doi: 10.1006/nimg.1998.0414
[46]	KONDZIELLA D, BENDER A, DISERENS K, et al. European Academy of Neurology guideline on the diagnosis of coma and other disorders of consciousness[J]. Eur J Neurol, 2020, 27(5): 741-756. doi: 10.1111/ene.v27.5

Prediction models of outcome for patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness: a systematic review

RichHTML

PDF (PC)

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 2

References 46

Related Articles 15

Metrics

Comments

Recommended 0

[1]	LIU Hua, WANG Liyuan, MA Xin, LI Jing, WANG Li. OBE-CDIO model of teaching for curriculum of exercise rehabilitation training [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2026, 32(3): 270-275.
[2]	CHEN Xiayao, DONG Ying, DONG Xue, MI Zhongxiang, CHENG Jun, ZHANG Aimin, LU Didi, WANG Jun, LIU Jude, AN Qianmo, GUO Hui, LIU Xiaochen, YU Zefeng. Empirical study of input, output, outcome and impact of community-based rehabilitation stations [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2026, 32(1): 83-89.
[3]	LI Hongwei, HUANG Binbin, ZHU Chuanhua, LI Wei. Effect of transcranial direct current stimulation on α-band brain connectivity in disorders of consciousness [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(9): 1050-1056.
[4]	YANG Tongnian, REN Jie, XIAO Hui. Effect of physical activity on anxiety for children and adolescents: a systematic review of systematic reviews [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(8): 883-888.
[5]	WANG Xiaofeng, HU Mengqiao, WANG Yan, WEI Kun, XU Wenzhu, REN Dan, MA Ye. Effect of exoskeleton robot-assisted gait training on lower limb function after stroke and spinal cord injury: a systematic review [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(8): 914-921.
[6]	GU Yiqing, CHENG Shupeng, LI Yongqiang, MAO Erli, LI Jian'an. Capping versus non-capping decannulation strategy in adult tracheostomized patients: a systematic review [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(6): 666-673.
[7]	WANG Mei, ZHU Wenping. Health benefits of physical activity in patients with type 2 diabetes: a systematic review of systematic reviews [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(5): 553-560.
[8]	YE Lü, CHANG Jing, LING Hairun. Effect of exercise intervention on internet behavioral addictions: a systematic review of systematic reviews [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(4): 431-440.
[9]	ZHU Zhiqiang, XU Qiaoling, SHAO Xueyun. Health benefits of physical activity for obese and overweight children: a systematic review of systematic reviews [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(3): 296-305.
[10]	CAI Qian, ZHANG Xi, SU Hairong, LIU Na, HUANG Ying, LI Jiqiang, XIA Jin'gen, ZHENG Decai. Inspiratory muscle training for weaning outcomes in patients with weaning failure: a systematic review [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(3): 306-313.
[11]	HUA Longang, LAI Haifang, YANG Wei, LIU Yong, YE Xiangming. Effect of transcutaneous auricular vagus nerve stimulation on patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(3): 339-347.
[12]	XU Xiaohong, ZHONG Xiaoke, SUN Siyi, ZHANG Qi, CHENG Huaichun. Psychological benefits of art therapy for older adults with mild cognitive impairment: a systematic review [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(2): 165-171.
[13]	Committee of Disorders of Consciousness Rehabilitation, Chinese Association of Rehabilitation Medicine. Chinese expert consensus on comprehensive rehabilitation and non-invasive neuromodulation for prolonged disorders of consciousness [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(12): 1365-1375.
[14]	DUAN Fuwen, ZHANG Beiqi, LI Li. Preventive effect of exercise interventions on sport-related concussion: a systematic review [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(12): 1385-1397.
[15]	LIU Dongfei, YAN Huiyi, YANG Fan, ZHANG Shuai. Effect of exercise interventions on multidimensional health outcomes in children and adolescents with Down syndrome: a meta-analysis [J]. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Theory and Practice, 2025, 31(12): 1398-1413.